A
petition hosted by MoveOn.org is circulating protesting comments made by North
Carolina Governor Pat McCrory about the curriculum in colleges and universities
in the state. He made his remarks
on Bill Bennett's radio show, and they infuriated faculty members at Chapel
Hill and elsewhere. Responding to Bennett's question about what he plans
to do with education, the Governor declared himself a "big vocational training
advocate" and regretted that "the educational elite" have produced an
undergraduate program filled with "courses that have no chance of getting
people jobs." Bennett cited "gender studies" with a laugh, and McCrory
termed it a "subsidized course" and told listeners, "If you want to take a
gender studies that's fine, go to a private school and take it. But I
don't want to subsidize that if that's not going to get someone a job."
He added that he planned "to adjust my education curriculum to what business
and commerce needs." He insisted that "I do believe in liberal arts
education," but stated that the funding formula for higher education in the
state must change so that it will favor more skills-based studies.
It's
a common sense position echoed by state leaders across the country, many of
whom are pressured by big employers in their states to produce more graduates
who can fill empty positions. The professors didn't see it that
way. UNC law professor and former dean Gene Nichol told
the Raleigh News-Observer, "It is hugely disappointing to see Governor
McCrory jump on the 'know-nothing' bandwagon to try to please Bill
Bennett. He does Glenn Beck proud." The head of gender studies at
Chapel Hill told
Inside Higher Ed that McCrory's attack was "kind of frightening, while a
religion studies professor told
the Charlotte Observer, ""I don't know what kinds of jobs McCrory wishes
for UNC graduates, but his comments certainly suggest that he has low
expectations for UNC students and for the state of North Carolina, which is
disappointing - and insulting."
The
petition itself states, "We need to stand up to this hypocrisy now . . ." and
its lead statement reads, "Governor McCrory: Stop your effort to dismantle UNC
system liberal arts arts programs. UNC includes top-tier institutions
attended by students from all over the world, in part because of its diverse
and rigorous coursework. Give UNC the respect it deserves and keep your politics
out of it."
The tone
is juvenile, the fear overdone. It is easy to read McCrory's utterance as
simply an adjustment to off-campus conditions, not a "dismantling." But the
petition has collected 12,678 signatures, and McCrory's words have made their
way to the Washington Post, the Huffington Post, and Forbes,
each with critical comments attached.


Comments (3)
It was actually Bennett and the NC Governor who were being juvenile.
Gender studies is a favorite target of right-wing cheap shots. But one could just as easily aim at targets like leisure studies and sports marketing in the business school.
Missing from any of this is any actual data on whether graduates in these fields get jobs or not. In the absence of data, they are just spouting hot air.
Furthermore, if those guys knew anything about higher education financing, they'd realize that gender studies is subsidized far less than expensive fields like engineering and science.
When you throw in tuition, it may actually be the case that the genders studies students are subsidizing the expensive fields!
Posted by Jonathan | February 8, 2013 1:18 PM
Posted on February 8, 2013 13:18
Why would an English prof. like Baurlein support McCrory's naked anti-intellectualism?
Posted by conservative critic | February 8, 2013 2:57 PM
Posted on February 8, 2013 14:57
I would assume that were graduates of X studies programs employable in positions related to their studies which provide sufficient income to live and pay back loans, then the faculty of these programs would be proclaiming this far and wide. If this isn't the case, then perhaps they *are* being used as pawns to subsidize others, but I wonder why the program faculty willingly participate in such a scam, given such program's focus on the evils facing members of category X.
Posted by Mike Lutz | February 10, 2013 5:43 PM
Posted on February 10, 2013 17:43